VP debate: Did gender play a role in the interruptions?

  • 2020-10-08 18:08:07
Wednesday night's vice-presidential debate was widely seen as civil, but with few memorable moments. Yet one exchange that resonated strongly with many viewers - especially women - was when Kamala Harris responded to Mike Pence interrupting her by smiling and saying: "Mr Vice-President, I'm speaking… If you don't mind letting me finish, then we can have a conversation." In fact, Ms Harris responded to an interruption with the phrase "I'm speaking" on three occasions. Many considered these to be poignant moments that chimed with their own experiences of seeing women struggling for air time, or being interrupted by men in work situations. Ms Harris was "clearly prepared" for interruptions, says Deborah Tannen, a linguistics professor at Georgetown University and expert in gender differences in language use. She came across as "respectful" by saying "Mr Vice-President", while "I'm speaking" was not accusatory in the way "stop interrupting me" would have been, Dr Tannen told the AFP. "Clearly her challenge throughout the whole debate was to avoid coming across as aggressive," she said. "There's a double bind for women - because anything you do to come across as a forceful candidate violates expectations for women. I think she walked that fine line extremely well."

Related